I think the pumpkin picture would look great with either a rust or taupe frame.

You might want to try a gold frame if you want a little flashier.

Thank you for your input! I don't think Mill Hill makes those little frames in gold, but I agree, it would add some sparkle! (But, I could probably take the Taupe and paint over it. 😃)

Just my two cents. I think I would like the rust better, since you've already got dark frames, it would look more coordinated.

Thank you, friends! I ordered the kit today, and went with the rust, because I think it will look better with my fall decor. I also ordered the Mill Hill Harvest Corn kit, that I'm hoping to work up as a companion piece with the White Pumpkins, and I thought rust would go well with both. We'll see.