It would depend on if you what it to look new or used. Blanc (white) for new, 3865 Winter White for slightly used, or 762
V LT Pearl Gray for very used

Yes I have that for a baseball. But I looking colored for softball. It's a yellowish color with some very light green tint

The closest I can find to a yellowish color with a green tint is 3046 MD Yellow Beige or 3047 LT Yellow Beige.

Thanks I will check that out. Great

I would also look at the dmc light effects in fluorescent yellow for a brand new ball or maybe 4070 in dmc color variations and finally 166 regular dmc. Good luck.

Leanne. Big thanks for your information on looking for softball colors. I look in the friendship bracelet making. I found the color I was looking for. You was very helpful. Thanks again